Secure the factual basis first.
Before making a declaration, documents, values and correspondence should be organised. Without that basis every decision is vulnerable.
Division of the estate
Private valuation report in an estate dispute
When estate values are disputed, a private valuation report can help. When it is useful and where its limits lie.
Your contact
Mag. Bernhard Brandauer
Attorney · BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte, Salzburg
Inheritance matters are handled by Mag. Bernhard Brandauer together with a coordinated team. We examine the will, compulsory portion, gifts and deadlines and tell you clearly where you stand.
6 July 2026 · Mag. Bernhard Brandauer, Rechtsanwalt
In inheritance disputes, the value of individual assets often determines the compulsory portion, a buyout or the division. Real estate, a business share, jewellery or a collection can be assessed very differently. A private report can make the discussion more factual.
This article explains when a separate valuation is useful, what documents it needs and why it does not automatically end the dispute. It is a tool for negotiation and preparation, not a substitute for strategy.
Classify your situation
Which step is sensible now?
Answer one short question. You receive initial orientation on the likely next step.
Already know you want to get in touch? Go straight to the enquiry form.
What should the private report clarify?
A private valuation report is strongest when it answers a concrete valuation question instead of merely confirming a desired figure.
All paths at a glance
Overview of all answers.
Focus: Estate division →
Pressure is a warning signal.
If the other side pushes for speed, check carefully what effect a declaration or payment would have. Time pressure does not replace a legal basis.
Structure lowers risk.
A clear next step is often better than a broad confrontation. Sort claim, evidence and goal before responding.
When a separate valuation is useful
When a separate valuation is useful
A private report is worthwhile when the other side uses sweeping figures or when one estate asset is decisive for the shares. With real estate, business assets or collections, a small valuation difference can have major consequences.
The valuation purpose matters. Is it about market value, a value at a specific date, a reduction in value or the plausibility of an existing estimate? The more precise the question, the more useful the result.
Which documents support the valuation
Which documents support the valuation
A valuation depends on the material provided. For real estate, land register, condition, contracts, photos, prior reports, renovation needs and comparables matter. For movable items, origin, condition, market reference and invoices are relevant.
A party who only gives the valuer a desired number weakens their own position. A transparent set of materials with open uncertainties is stronger. It keeps the valuation usable in negotiations.
A good private report explains why a value is plausible. It does not replace a court decision, but it can show where an opposing figure is vulnerable.
How to use the report tactically
How to use the report tactically
The report should not be sent too quickly as a threat. First clarify what follows from it: settlement proposal, supplementing the inventory, counter-calculation or preparation of court steps.
In negotiations, a traceable valuation approach is often stronger than a maximum demand. Showing which assumptions matter can create willingness to talk sooner.
Frequent questions
Private reports in estate disputes
Is a private report binding? +
No. It does not automatically bind the other side. But it can structure negotiations and show why a valuation should be reviewed.
When is valuation especially important? +
When one estate asset significantly affects the share, a compulsory portion or a buyout. Then an unclear figure can distort the entire dispute.
Should I commission a report without legal review? +
The valuation question should be clear first. Otherwise you may receive an expensive document that does not answer the legally decisive issue.
Topics
Estate valuationPrivate reportEstate divisionInheritance dispute
Inheritance dispute, an overlooked compulsory portion, a doubtful will?
In inheritance law, deadlines and evidence decide. Call us directly or send an email, callback within one business day.
Contact
A direct line to the firm.
Address
BRANDAUER Rechtsanwälte GmbH Giselakai 51 5020 Salzburg
Phone
+43 662 6280000